By Boun | July 11th, 2011
Posted in Business
J.P. Morgan Chase & Co., the nation’s second largest bank by assets, has dismissed more than a thousand debt collection lawsuits against borrowers across the U.S. over credit card loans that went bad.
The bank began quietly dismissing lawsuits in state courts in April. Lawsuits were dropped in California, Florida, Illinois, New Jersey, and New York. Credit card customers in those five states owed J.P. Morgan $45.9 billion on outstanding credit cards (current and delinquent accounts) as of March 31. The bank has a total of more than $100 billion in credit card account assets. They did not disclose the value of the lawsuits that were dropped or release specifics on the exact number of cases dismissed.
In-house lawyers for the bank asked judges in state courts to withdraw pending cases without prejudice. Thomas Donnelly, a state court judge in Chicago, said he wasn’t given an explanation by the bank’s lawyers but did dismiss the cases without prejudice. Without prejudice means that the bank can later refile their lawsuits if they choose to proceed again in the future.
Mitch Grant, who is a lawyer contracted to handle debt collection cases for J.P. Morgan in Palm Beach County, FL., said he was told by the banks in-house lawyers that suits in Florida were dropped. The paperwork to verify the validity of the credit card debt contained “irregularities.” J.P. Morgan and other credit card lenders have been criticized by judges all over the country for producing sloppy or even fraudulent documentation of debts.
A widespread problem in credit card collection suits and foreclosure practices is “robo-signing.” Robo-signing occurs when employees of a company sign documents without reviewing them. Sometimes an employee signs hundreds of documents in a day. It has led to faulty paperwork and wrongful foreclosures.
Deficiencies in credit card collection suits are far worse than foreclosure cases say Judge Philip Strainer of Richmond County, NY. Other judges agree. Last year, Judge Strainer dismissed 150 debt collection lawsuits filed by J.P. Morgan, citing that paperwork submitted by the bank “appeared to be signed in large numbers by only a few individuals.”
J.P. Morgan has not confirmed or denied dropping lawsuits in large numbers. Paul Hardwick, spokesman for the bank, said the bank considers “our collections strategy to be proprietary.” Lawyers representing debtors who were taken to court by J.P. Morgan has never seen a bank dropped that many lawsuits at once.
According to industry estimates, roughly 94% of debt collection lawsuits result in default judgments against borrowers. Some judges who rule on those lawsuits said the average amount sought is roughly $1000.
Many banks use outside law firms to sue borrowers. J.P. Morgan uses a team of in-house lawyers to pursue defaulted borrowers in majority of their debt collection lawsuits. Those lawyers are scattered all over the U.S. Some of those lawyers were told by company officials that all company collection offices will be shut down by the start of 2012.