Tribal Owned Payday Loan Companies Profit from Rules
The sovereign immunity granted to tribes by the U.S. government produces hefty profits for tribal-owned payday loan companies. Tribes are shielded from interest rate caps and other industry regulations. Online lenders have become attracted to the “sovereign-loan” model, pursuing partnerships with economically struggling tribes – piggy backing on their freedom from state and U.S. lending laws.
Tribes doing business with online lenders made about 12,500 loans per month in 2010, equivalent to about $420 million in payday loans that year. Payday loans are approved to consumers who can secure a loan with their next paycheck. The average loan is about $400. No credit check is required, thus making it more convenient for cash-strapped consumers to borrow.
While states are increasingly cracking down on abuses by the traditional payday loan industry, seventeen U.S. states have capped interest rates on loans or banned them entirely. It has resulted in payday loan volume falling to $38.5 billion in 2009, down 24% from 2007, according to Stephens Inc., an investment-banking firm in Little Rock, Arkansas.
Traditional payday lenders have tried to avoid interest rate caps by incorporating their business in states like Delaware and Utah, who have no maximum rates, and then impose the higher rate on consumers throughout the U.S. That practice was defeated when Pennsylvania’s highest court ruled last October that Cash America International Inc., the largest payday lender by revenue, had to abide by the states’ interest and licensing rules and not Neveda’s rules where the company is incorporated.
U.S. states have been “powerless” to stop tribal-owned payday lenders according to Colorado Attorney General John Suthers. Since 2009, he has tried to force the Miami Nation of Oklahoma and the Santee Sioux Nation in South Dakota (both payday lenders) to stop making loans to Colorado residents. AG Suthers failed when Colorado’s Supreme Court ruled in Novemeber that both lenders were protected from enforcement action as arms of American Indian tribes.
Of 300 internet payday lending companies, more than 35 are owned by American Indian tribes. Online lenders seeking partnership with economically struggling tribes, and tribes already operating casinos, are expected to pursue new market opportunities in the payday loan industry – increasing the number of tribal owned companies to 400.

